Is the Duval Loop Gone for Good? Mayor Is Betting on New Island Hopper

As another transportation service prepares to disappear, the mayor is betting on the Island Hopper to deliver a more sustainable alternative.

Share
Is the Duval Loop Gone for Good? Mayor Is Betting on New Island Hopper
Key West Mayor Sam Kaufman recognizes the challenges presented by changing the island's transportation system every few years. Will the Island Hopper put the city back on track? (KEVIN ASSAM)

As Key West prepares to replace another transportation service, the mayor is betting on the Island Hopper to deliver a more sustainable alternative.

With on-demand rideshare service Conch Connect gone and Key West Rides nearing its final trip, could the already-suspended Duval Loop be the next public transportation service to disappear for good?

At Mayor Sam Kaufman's most recent press conference, that sounded like a real possibility, though not necessarily for the reason you might think.

Key West is preparing to roll out its new Island Hopper service on November 30. Kaufman suggested Tuesday that the suspended Duval Loop may not need to return at all if the Island Hopper can effectively replicate its route.

"I'm not sure we need the Duval Loop," Kaufman said during his November 10 press conference. "I think we have to see how [the Island Hopper] works."

Responding to a question from me about the disappearance of Conch Connect, the suspension of the Duval Loop, and the impending end of Key West Rides (which ends at the end of the month), Kaufman acknowledged that the city has struggled to maintain a consistent transportation system.

"It's challenging because every couple years we change our transportation system and that's not good because people need consistency," he said.

"They need to know where they can get the bus, how to get the bus. And over time that helps grow the system. If you change it every year, every three years, people lose confidence, they don't understand it, it becomes confusing and so on."

The Island Hopper, which will operate clockwise and counterclockwise routes around the island, represents what Kaufman called a "very good first step." He said its downtown segment closely resembles the Duval Loop's route, potentially making a separate downtown service unnecessary.

But for an island that should theoretically be among the easiest places in America to navigate without a car, the mayor offered a reality check.

"I don't think we're ever going to be at a place where people are going to give up their cars. At least not in the short term," he said, while stressing that public transportation remains essential.

Kaufman plans to personally test the Island Hopper on opening day, inviting residents to meet him at Glen Archer and Northside Drive in the morning of November 30.

Rides will be free from November 30 through December 6 as the city promotes the new service.

Meanwhile, the outgoing Key West Rides program, which allowed residents to book on-demand shared transportation between designated stops, received a rather curious sendoff from the mayor: it was a success that became unsustainable.

Kaufman said demand for the service had grown as other low-cost options disappeared, with riders increasingly resorting to telephone bookings that strained city staffing.

That was despite the availability of a mobile booking app. When asked whether the app itself had failed to function as intended, Kaufman acknowledged hearing from the transportation department that residents had experienced numerous issues and frequently needed to call instead.

Palm & Prejudice also contacted Key West Transportation Director Rogelio Hernandez to clarify whether Key West Rides' demise was primarily attributable to funding, staffing limitations, or problems with its booking app, and whether alternatives to discontinuing the service had been explored. Hernandez did not respond to the inquiry.

Kaufman also floated a potential long-term funding solution: dedicating revenue from any future parking-rate increases to public transportation.

He stressed that he would not support increasing parking rates for locals. But with tourists accounting for what he estimated to be an overwhelming majority of paid parking, Kaufman suggested that tapping additional visitor-generated revenue to fund transportation for residents, particularly those with lower incomes, was something of a no-brainer.

For now, the Duval Loop's future remains an open question. And the Island Hopper, before carrying its first passenger, may already be shaping the fate of one of Key West's once most recognizable public transportation services.

Key West's free rides may be disappearing, but independent journalism still needs a fare. Leave a tip to keep us rolling.

Tip